FIG PUBLICATION NO. 35Enhancing the Representation of Under-Represented Groups in FIGThis publication in pdf-format Table of ContentsPreface
|
Women Entering the Profession - Canadian Case StudyAs a professional body and as individual surveyors we want to be seen as “modern” and that means behaving in such a way. Young women considering our profession will want to know that they will be included and respected. At both the individual level and the organizational level we can ask ourselves if our speech and actions reflect our desire to say truly “the profession is wide open to women.” We should all ask ourselves if geomatics is a profession to which we would be proud to include our sons and daughters. J. Anne Cole, Northern Regional Surveyor, Ministry of Consumer and Business Services, Government of Ontario, Canada: Recruiting the Best and the Brightest - Reflections from a Personal Perspective, FIG Under-represented Groups Newsletter 3/05. |
FIG represents an important international dialogue and synergy in developing the surveying profession. Thus, students who are future professionals would benefit from being connected to the organisation and to be exposed to global perspectives at an early stage of their studies. FIG offers students a possibility for the students to develop a professional commitment, a chance to meet people of the same age in the same situation and a chance to meet experienced colleagues. A gathering of students connected to FIG would begin the process of establishing a professional and social network with personal contacts amongst the next generation of surveyors. It will also enable networking of new friends and future fellow workers.
Another aspect of the meetings between students from different countries is the potential of exchange studies. It is easier to establish a contact with a university abroad if personal contacts are already made. The experience of exchange studies brings personal development and understanding for different cultures, which will be important in their future work as a surveyor.
Moreover, to encourage survey students’ and young surveyors’ participation in an FIG Congress or Working Week is a stimulant to FIG and brings important rejuvenation to the organization. Active participation of the next generation in FIG activities is very important for the future for all professions connected to the organization. Students and young surveyors involved in FIG who do not meet all the needs of today, will be tasked with meeting the challenges of tomorrow. Exposure to an international organisation such as FIG can only promote their development and thus the strength of the profession.
FIG recognises that students and young professionals develop solutions to tomorrow’s professional challenges, and with their special creativity and idealism can make a significant contribution to FIG.
FIG encourages students and young professionals to participate within FIG.
FIG will identify the problems facing youth within and particular to our profession, and will prepare proposals for solving those problems with the participation of young people through their formal and informal structures.
FIG will evaluate and implement such proposals.
FIG will promote international co-operation for students.
More than 100 countries are represented in FIG and it has emerged as a global network of surveyors from around the world. In the past years, FIG has organised international conferences, symposiums and working weeks in different parts of the world including China, Thailand, South Korea, Columbia, Egypt, Morocco, Turkey, Ghana, South Africa and Kenya. However, the core membership and activities of FIG are still often perceived to be generated by a small minority of white males who dominate the FIG higher management. There is a lack of full representation of linguistic and cultural minorities as well as those from countries with limited financial resources in the FIG. This lack of diversity and representation could affect not only the credibility of FIG as a truly inclusive international organisation but also its ability to develop cross cultural dialogue and its capacity to work effectively in all parts of the world.
In carrying out several of its objectives, FIG needs to further intensify its efforts to bring into the fold minorities from other linguistic, cultural and other backgrounds. Only then, can the FIG mission be achieved through acceptance and implementation of its standards at national levels. The interest in FIG activities from various cultural, linguistic and regional backgrounds represents a significant opportunity for FIG to expand, but this cannot be taken for granted. FIG will have to be proactive and take affirmative action to ensure that different sections of the international society are effectively represented. While upholding its emphasis on quality and merit, it will have to further develop a corporate environment and culture within which the participation of all groups is encouraged.
The 'diversity' agenda includes a wide range of considerations and personal characteristics, including age, race, sexuality, religion and social class, as factors that need to be taken into account in equal opportunities programmes. The danger is that 'women' and for that matter 'gender' have to compete with these other issues. But this is a false division: because gender issues, and women's rights in particular, should cut across and over-arch all these other issues. This is particularly true of ethnicity, as it seems that the surveying profession has difficulty coping with people who are both female and black, whereas they are more accustomed to dealing with black males who, traditionally, have held low status and manual work jobs on building sites.
As for disability, that is usually viewed as a reason for leaving the profession not joining it! But new requirements under the Disability Discrimination Acts have resulted in more disabled surveyors, architects and designers being employed if only to 'audit' the access aspects of a building. But other minority groups do not solely consist of men, in many cases they are the majority of their group, for example in the case of Afro-Caribbean people in Britain. So it would seem that the next challenge for the surveying profession and wider construction industry is to recruit from a wider demographic base, and 'to juggle all the diversity balls in the air at once without dropping women'.
Ethnic under-representation UK Case studyEthnic minority individuals (in the UK) compose far less than 1% of membership of the professional bodies in construction. Whilst some construction organisations have welcomed and supported ethnic minority professionals, from the research it is clear there are problems to be addressed, not least the images and attitudes held by some within the industry as to the perceived place and role of minority individuals within the industry. Clara H. Greed, Ethnic Minorities in Construction in Britain: Exclusion or Inclusion, FIG Under-represented Groups Newsletter 4/00. |
FIG recognises that in order to be a fully representative, international and effective organisation, it must undertake proactive steps to ensure greater participation of cultural and linguistic minorities, particularly from countries with financial constrains and incorporate their perspectives.
FIG acknowledges that being an inclusive organisation requires that the principles of equal opportunity, respect for diversity and a corporate culture that is cross-cultural, fair, transparent, open and encouraging is embedded in its work.
All levels and bodies of FIG will routinely consider ways to enhance the participation of linguistic, cultural minorities and those from countries facing financial constraints. All levels and bodies of FIG will develop mechanisms for ensuring this takes place and will identify entry points and opportunities to enhance the participation of minorities within the work of FIG.
From Rural Informal Education to Professional Qualifications - Kenyan Case StudyBernadette M. Gitari is a professional Valuation and Estate Management Surveyor licensed to practice in Kenya, East Africa and has 23 years experience in this field. Her initial education was in rural education but she went on to professional qualifications. She learnt about FIG in the year 2001 and was able to attend the Conference in Washington DC in April 2002 and participated in the joint commissions on Gender and Underrepresented Groups. One of her main agendas as a member of the Institution of Surveyors of Kenya Council is to set up a body within the Institution that would cater to women’s needs in terms of career development, for women in surveying, sensitizing those who would wish to join the surveying profession in Kenya, the need to network with other women in the surveying profession from other countries in the world as well as attending international meetings and forums on surveying. ‘Personalities’, FIG Under-represented Groups Newsletter 3/03 |
The recognition of the importance of actively seeking greater participation and perspectives of women, students and cultural, linguistic minorities and those from under represented countries requires a review of existing FIG policies and action plans. Among the areas of focus should be gathering further information on representation at all levels (including working weeks and congresses) and their causes, encouraging fair competition for minority groups, gender mainstreaming, resources for supporting pluralism, moving towards a multicultural and gender balanced and democratically elected council, and dissemination of information in a manner that reaches a wider range of potential FIG participants.
During the past several years the Task Force and the Working Group have prepared a number of recommendations. Several of these recommendations were/are already implemented. The following is an overview of those recommendations.
FIG encourages the local organizers of the Congresses, the Working Weeks and the Regional Conferences to facilitate the attendance of young surveyors and students. The practice of Regional Conferences should be continued.
An evaluation of the participants concerning gender, age and Commissions is necessary to get more information about the participants of Congresses, Working Weeks and Regional Conferences and to implement targeted activities.
There is greater potential for local survey students to participate when an event takes place in their home country. A low fee for students should be fixed to facilitate the attendance of students.
The organisers should enable the attendance of 20 students to assist.
Organisers should provide meeting points with tea and coffee or lunch to facilitate the contact of participants.
The organisation of a student’s session should offer the opportunity to talk about experiences, differences between their educations and the possibilities to exchange studies.
Organisers should enable Commission meetings or workshops during a Congress or Working Week for presentation of papers for under represented groups. This should be followed up by discussions in the main Commission meetings, including sessions dedicated to the issues.
Participation in the Task Forces or Joint Commission Working Groups meetings should be encouraged from a wider range of Commission participants, particularly those involved in core commission and management activities.
Hosts of Congresses, Working Weeks or Regional Conferences could possibly implement a symposium (Cadastre Day, Hydrographic Day, …) with simultaneous translation to facilitate the attendance of national participants when it is not possible to have a simultaneous translation for the whole event.
Speakers might have the possibility to present their papers in their own language, but in this case slides have to be translated into English, and a colleague provides the translation into English, along with the oral presentation.
Member associations play an important role to enhance the situation of under-represented groups in FIG. They may influence who will participate at Congresses, Working Weeks and Regional or National Conferences. Delegations should be balanced based on gender and culture.
The attendance of young professionals and students should be supported and sponsored. Member associations should be interested so that a surveyor of the future has a breadth of approach to his/her future profession.
Member associations should encourage the participation of under represented groups in the profession by directing funding to such persons to enable them to study surveying.
Another way for students to take part in FIG is through universities. The Universities could arrange suitable contests to find interested students, and sponsor their participation at the Working Week. To sponsor a student is a great chance for both the University and for the specific student. The student becomes an ambassador for the university, which leads to advertisement.
FIG’s technical work is led by the Commissions. For national delegates as well as for corresponding members, Commissions should be a platform for an exchange of experiences and knowledge. Commissions should give information with topical homepages and newsletters and facilitate the attendance of Commission meetings.
There is a need for improved co-operation between universities and FIG. It is important to create a platform to maintain regularity in the co-operation because students are involved in the work only for a limited time. This platform could be the link between FIG and international students’ organisations.
Another way of helping students to be part of FIG is if experienced members stand by students and become some kind of mentor. This mentorship would lead to pleasure for both the mentor and the student since they both can inspire each other. The student will come with new ideas from an educational perspective while the Surveyor inspires the student with knowledge and experience. The mentor and the student could have their contact during the year via e-mail for example and then meet during Congresses or the Working Weeks.
The General Assembly should implement gender mainstreaming to mobilise all general policies and measures specifically for the purpose of achieving equality by actively and openly taking into account at the planning stage their possible effects on the respective situation of men and women (gender perspective).
The General Assembly elects the Council members and Chairpersons. Besides a regional and cultural balance gender should also be taken into account.
For each official position within FIG a check should be performed before any candidacy is accepted, to verify that the candidate is able to speak English with the following feature: slowly, with a systematic accentuation of all syllables, carefully avoiding uncommon words.
Students seldom have the possibility to finance their participation in Congresses and Working Weeks. Some kind of sponsoring is necessary for the students to be able to join the meetings. Opportunities for scholarships should be encouraged e.g. through the FIG Foundation.
One of the Vice-President’s main topics should be gender and youth policies. He or she will supervise the implementation of this policy document in FIG.
FIG has undertaken several initiatives, such as the quarterly newsletter promoting the participation and perspectives of women, youth and minorities, demonstrating its increasing commitment to diversity in representation and plurality in perspective. However, it can learn from case studies from surveying organisations around the world which provide good practices in this respect. In this section, examples of good practice from professional associations, public institutions and universities from a number of countries across the globe are showcased. It is not intended to be a representative sample, but rather a collection of experiences from countries in which FIG representation has been easy to obtain.
The American Congress on Surveying and Mapping (ACSM) |
ACSM Student Chapters have been encouraged by the association at colleges and universities to support young people and new entrants to the surveying and mapping professions. Students also receive discounted membership fees, and discounted registration fees for conferences.
ACSM offers several college and university scholarships in a variety of areas. In the recent past, some scholarships have been designed by ACSM’s Forum for Women in Surveying and specifically targeted to women students. To assist employers in finding well qualified candidates at the entry level, ACSM offers a career fair, which notifies students about job openings.
ACSM’s Forum for Women in Surveying produced advertising guidelines for professional and technical publications to help eliminate discriminatory advertising in trade journals and exhibits. The Forum has also produced guidelines for professional and technical writing to help eliminate gender bias in technical and professional publications.
The UK Institution of Civil Engineers (ICE) |
ICE has created an Equal Opportunities Committee (ICEFLOE) to promote differing backgrounds, skills, and abilities in the association. ICEFLOE has produced fact sheets and articles about flexible working, age discrimination, ethnic minorities, disabilities, and bullying.
To increase awareness of equal opportunities, ICEFLOE has (1) conducted a photo exhibition about real people in real careers, (2) arranged publicity about engineering and construction careers in women’s magazines, (3) participated in an employers’ forum on age discrimination, (4) sponsored radio coverage about engineering careers, (5) reviewed disability access in key locations, (6) held on-line debates, (7) provided speakers for schools, and (8) held workshops and receptions.
ICEFLOE prepared a Diversity Monitoring Form for active members of the association to help reduce obstacles to equal opportunities. ICEFLOE also monitors ICE practices and policies. In order to research the need for equal opportunities and to reduce obstacles to equal opportunities, ICEFLOE has prepared a Skills Shortage Questionnaire. To support and encourage members of the association, ICEFLOE has provided personal responses to members’ inquiries, and sponsored awards for diversity awareness and enhancement.
ICEFLOE has also collaborated with several other engineering and physics organizations, and with societies of non-English speaking engineers, and with engineers of various cultures.
The American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) |
ASCE seeks to promote the understanding and appreciation of diversity, particularly through its Committee on Diversity. The Committee was created to promote the proactive inclusion of various backgrounds, skills, and experiences to enhance opportunities within the profession. The ASCE committee has prepared links to diversify resources, programs, and tips. Included are tips for women and people of colour to engage others in diversity awareness.
The committee has prepared lists of leadership skills, and links to e-mentoring programs. As part of its outreach initiative, the ASCE committee has promoted the spread of diversity awareness to accreditation organizations for university and college programs in engineering and technology.
German Association of Surveying (DVW), Society for Geodesy, Geoinformation and Land Management |
To support women in the surveying profession and within the association, DVW established a Working Group "Women in DVW" in 1989. After seventeen years of work the Working Group now has a broad acceptance and is supported financially by DVW. The Working Group is linked to German Commission 1 “Profession”.
"Women in DVW" built up a women’s network in the field of the surveying profession and organises several activities during the annual INTERGEO, the German national congress and international trade fair, to promote and support women: "Women in DVW" is represented at the DVW booth in the exhibition area during the INTERGEO, which offers a good opportunity to get in contact with female and male colleagues. During several congresses "Women in DVW" arranged panel discussions and presentations with female aspects, for example "How to establish an Enterprise" or "Reform of the Curriculum at Universities.” The network built up a database for mentoring. An annual weekend-workshop of "Women in DVW" was created to increase the network and to prepare all activities.
DVW determined guidelines in 2005 to support students and young professionals in preparation for governmental services. Within the frame of financial resources, DVW finances entire or partially for example the participation at seminars and congresses or for semesters or diploma thesis in foreign countries. Students fees for congresses and seminars as well as membership fees are subsidised.
Affirmative Action – South African case study |
At the University of Cape Town in South Africa (UCT), a number of measures have been adopted to counter the imbalances perpetuated by apartheid and previous colonial systems which have led to various groups being underrepresented in the profession, including Black people who are in the majority in South Africa. One of the approaches is affirmative action as seen in the South African experience. Persons from underrepresented groups are actively “recruited, trained and developed to compete equally and contribute to the development of the company”. The process of implementation of affirmative action should be completed within a specified time period and should not be continued indefinitely.
Proactive approaches and resources are needed to address problems faced in affirmative recruitment. Affirmative recruitment in the survey industry is hampered by poor skills/academic base of school-leavers – racially skewed in favour of the white population group due to historic apartheid education discrimination. There is a great shortage of persons from underrepresented groups who are suitably qualified for professional positions. Recruitment and retention of such persons is thus a great problem and lack of commitment to an employer results, often with the non-white/female surveyor job-swapping frequently chasing after the highest salary.
A highly successful support programme has been running for many years for students from educationally disadvantaged backgrounds. This programme adds another year to the degree programme (which is usually 4 years) and is based on high contact levels with students, assistance and mentoring with all aspects of the transition to University, and additional academic tutoring. Some students from rural areas have never ridden a bicycle, seen or used an elevator, and may never have ridden in a passenger car. There are many challenges in teaching highly technical subjects to those who have potential, but have had very little exposure to technology. Some of the students from this programme have gone on to be among the top performers in the Faculty.
The programme at the University of Cape Town, as well as the local branch of the Institute, has endeavoured over the past years to be as inclusive as possible in social functions. Such issues as finding sponsorship for alcoholic as well as non-alcoholic drinks at functions, catering for different food preparation requirements such as Halaal, and making sure that activities include women on an equal footing to men, are areas which have improved. Increasingly, organisations involved with Geomatics are becoming conscienitized to such issues.
Addressing Gender Imbalance through Equal Opportunity Policy – Australia |
In 1997, the School of Spatial Sciences, Curtin University, Perth, Australia was awarded the Equal Opportunity prize for its initiatives to address gender imbalance amongst its staff and students by two ground-breaking appointments of female staff. The present female male ratio of the School's staff is higher than that typically found within the surveying and mapping industry. In addition, equal employment opportunity initiatives aimed at increasing diversity have meant that of the 13 full-time academic staff members employed by the School in 1996, the countries represented included Argentina, Australia, China, Greece, the United Kingdom and the United States of America. The School of Spatial Sciences has taken the initiative of advertising vacant positions as widely as possible. (Graham D Lodwick, Australia, FIG Under-represented Groups Newsletter 1/98)
To address the inadequate gender ratio in its courses, the School produced a promotional video "Make your Mark". The translation of the School video by means of dubbing into languages other than English is another possibility. The video represents a significant milestone in attempts to improve the number of females in non-traditional areas of study. In the surveying industry, this is the first video specifically targeted towards this objective and was funded by a Curtin University Equity and Access grant and serves to internationally recruit the best persons available while adhering to Equal Employment Opportunities (EEO) guidelines. The School also rewards the efforts of EEO target groups and conducts an annual prize giving ceremony awarding prizes for special achievement.
Encouraging Girls and Young Women to Choose a Technical Career – German Case Study |
This is a project, founded by the equal opportunity officers of four universities of applied sciences (FH) in the Northwest of Lower Saxony, Germany, in 1993: FH Oldenburg, FH Osnabrück, FH Ostfriesland and FH Wilhelmshaven. It is funded by the Ministry of Science and Culture in Lower Saxony. The project organises one week Summer Schools for girls ages 16 and up to encounter natural sciences and engineering. The concept is to offer hands on experiences as well as lectures, guided tours and panel discussions with positive role models: female students and practitioners. In some Summer Schools Job Shadowing or Worksite Tours are also made possible for the “practice students”. In addition special 2-3 day courses on selected subjects are organised during spring and fall vacations, e.g. geoinformatics, physics, mathematics and environmental engineering (especially active in developing this module.
FH Oldenburg (together with Carl von Ossietzky University Oldenburg) offers Open Houses at the university of applied sciences especially for young women (especially active in developing this module: FH Wilhelmshaven) offers career guidance classes for groups of schoolgirls, that are being held at the schools(11th trough 13th grade), providing insights into professional life in science and engineering (especially active in developing this module: FH Osnabrück) founded women’s networks of professionals in multiple fields of engineering and business (especially active in developing this module: FH Oldenburg) offers further education for female engineers, who readmit the workplace after a family break (especially active in developing this module: FH Ostfriesland) started a collection in the field of literature regarding women and technology. In cooperation with the library of University of Applied Science in Oldenburg “Women – University – Technologies” was founded. In addition to providing books, every semester two lectures are held dealing with women studies in engineering (e.g. a study on the development of the typewriter from a users point of view), or on the status of women in science and technology (e.g. questioning the unwritten rule, that part-time work in the field of engineering is impossible to organise). (Dr. Renate Kosuch, FIG Under-represented Groups Newsletter 1/99)
Published in English
Published by The International Federation of Surveyors (FIG)
ISBN: 87-90907-53-1, August 2006, Frederiksberg, Denmark
Printed copies can be ordered from:
FIG Office, Kalvebod Brygge 31-33, DK-1780 Copenhagen V, DENMARK,
Tel: + 45 38 86 10 81, E-mail:
FIG@fig.net